The story of Robert Francis Prevost, the first American-born and first Augustinian Pope
— Made in Italy Stories —
On the evening of 8 May 2025, the eyes of the world turned once again toward the central balcony of Saint Peter’s Basilica. A conclave that had begun only the previous day had chosen a new Bishop of Rome, and when Robert Francis Prevost appeared before the crowd as Pope Leo XIV, history immediately acquired several new firsts. He was the 267th Successor of Saint Peter, the first Pope born in the United States, and the first member of the Order of Saint Augustine ever elected to the papacy. Yet reducing his story to those headlines would miss what is most interesting about him. Before the white cassock, before the balcony and before millions of people learned his name in a single evening, Prevost had already lived a life divided among the United States, Rome and, above all, Peru. His route to the papacy was not a straight road through Vatican offices. It passed through classrooms, poor parishes, seminaries, missionary houses, diocesan administration and years of work in communities far from the usual image of ecclesiastical power.
Robert Francis Prevost was born in Chicago on 14 September 1955, the youngest of three sons of Louis Marius Prevost and Mildred Agnes Martínez. His family background already contained something of the international character that would later define his life. Vatican News has described his father as being of French and Italian descent and his mother as being of Spanish descent. His father had served in the United States Navy during the Second World War and later devoted himself to education, first as a teacher and then as a school principal. His mother worked as a librarian. Both parents were deeply involved in their parish life, so religion for the young Robert was not something that existed only on Sunday mornings or inside a church building; it formed part of the rhythm of family life. He grew up in the Chicago area, attended Saint Mary School of the Assumption and then Saint Augustine Seminary High School in Holland, Michigan. The official Vatican biography preserves some wonderfully ordinary details from those years: he edited the school yearbook, served on the student council, led the library club and senior class, and played tennis and bowled. Future popes are usually remembered in solemn portraits, so it is healthy to remember that at some point one of them was also worrying about yearbook deadlines and bowling scores.
After graduating in 1973, Prevost entered Villanova University in Pennsylvania. His degree was not in theology but in mathematics, completed in 1977, alongside studies in philosophy. Mathematics is not the most obvious academic route to the papacy, although an ability to deal calmly with complicated problems is probably not the worst preparation for the job. More importantly, his university years coincided with a deepening attraction to Augustinian religious life. On 1 September 1977 he entered the novitiate of the Order of Saint Augustine in Saint Louis, in the Province of Our Mother of Good Counsel of Chicago. He made his first profession in 1978 and his solemn profession in 1981. The Augustinian tradition would remain central to his spiritual identity for the rest of his life, not merely as the name of the religious order to which he belonged but as a way of understanding community, interior life, service and unity.
His theological formation continued at the Catholic Theological Union in Chicago, where he obtained a licentiate in theology in 1981. Later that year he was ordained a deacon and was sent to Rome to study Canon Law at the Pontifical University of Saint Thomas Aquinas, better known as the Angelicum. He lived at the International College of Saint Monica, and on 19 June 1982 he was ordained a priest in the Chapel of Saint Monica. Rome therefore entered his biography decades before Rome would finally claim him as its bishop. He obtained his licentiate in Canon Law in 1984 and defended his doctoral dissertation in 1985 on the role of the local prior within the Order of Saint Augustine. It was a very specialised subject, but it also reflected a question that would follow him throughout his career: how should authority be exercised inside a community? In the years ahead, he would move repeatedly between pastoral life and institutional responsibility, learning both the theory of governance and the far less tidy reality of governing actual human beings.
His decisive experience, however, came not in Rome or Chicago but in Peru. In 1985 he was assigned to the Augustinian mission in Chulucanas, in the Piura region of northern Peru. There he served as parochial vicar of the Cathedral of the Holy Family and as Chancellor of the Territorial Prelature. After a brief return to the United States in 1987, where he worked as vocations and missions director for his province, he went back to Peru in 1988, this time to Trujillo. What followed was not a short missionary visit that could later be remembered nostalgically from a comfortable office. He spent eleven years there and carried an extraordinary number of responsibilities. He directed formation for Augustinian candidates, served as prior of the community, trained professed members of the order, taught Canon Law, Moral Theology and Patristics, worked as judicial vicar and served in parish ministry, including in a poor suburb of Trujillo. These years are essential to understanding the future Pope. Peru was not an exotic chapter added to an American biography. It became one of the central countries of his life.
The image that emerges from the Peruvian period is of a priest moving between very different worlds. One day might involve the technical precision of canon law, another the formation of young religious, another a parish problem in a poor neighbourhood, another the institutional demands of a seminary or diocese. This combination mattered. Prevost was developing the administrative experience that would later make him useful in Rome, but he was acquiring it while living close to communities facing practical social and economic difficulties. He also became fluent in Spanish and deeply integrated into Peruvian Church life. Years later, when he became Pope, Peru did not speak of him merely as a foreign missionary who had once passed through. It spoke of someone who had become part of the country's ecclesial history. In 2015 he acquired Peruvian citizenship by naturalization, giving formal expression to a relationship that had already become personal and pastoral.
In 1998 he was elected Provincial Prior of the Augustinian Province of Our Mother of Good Counsel and returned to the United States to assume that responsibility in 1999. Two years later came a far larger task. In 2001 the General Chapter of the Order of Saint Augustine elected him Prior General, effectively placing him at the head of the worldwide order. He was confirmed for a second six-year term in 2007. For twelve years, therefore, Prevost was required to think globally, visiting communities, dealing with different cultures and languages, and handling the problems that arise when a religious family is spread across continents. Those years also gave him long experience of Rome and of the universal Church. By the time his second term ended in 2013, he had already spent decades moving between local pastoral realities and international leadership. He returned to Chicago and worked again in formation and provincial governance, perhaps imagining that the most demanding chapter of his institutional life was behind him. History had other ideas.
On 3 November 2014 Pope Francis appointed him Apostolic Administrator of the Diocese of Chiclayo in Peru and Titular Bishop of Sufar. He arrived in the diocese only days later and was ordained a bishop on 12 December, the Feast of Our Lady of Guadalupe. His episcopal motto, In Illo Uno Unum, comes from Saint Augustine and expresses the idea that although Christians are many, they are one in Christ. The motto was not an ornamental Latin phrase chosen merely because a bishop is expected to have one. It summarised a theme that would repeatedly appear in Prevost's public language: unity without erasing difference, and communion rather than faction. In September 2015 Pope Francis appointed him Bishop of Chiclayo, making permanent what had begun as an administrative assignment.
His years as a bishop strengthened his position inside the Latin American Church. In 2018 he was elected second vice-president of the Peruvian Episcopal Conference and also served in roles connected with economic affairs, culture and education. Pope Francis gradually entrusted him with responsibilities beyond Peru as well. He became a member of the Congregation for the Clergy in 2019, Apostolic Administrator of Callao in 2020 and a member of the Congregation for Bishops later that year. These appointments placed him increasingly close to the process by which the Catholic Church identifies, evaluates and appoints bishops around the world. It is difficult to imagine a better education in the strengths and weaknesses of Church leadership than spending years observing who is chosen to lead dioceses, why they are chosen and what happens after they arrive.
The major turning point came in January 2023, when Pope Francis called Prevost to Rome and appointed him Prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops and President of the Pontifical Commission for Latin America, also giving him the dignity of archbishop. The Dicastery for Bishops is one of the most consequential offices in the Roman Curia because it plays a central role in the selection of bishops for much of the Catholic world. Prevost therefore moved from governing one diocese to helping evaluate the future leadership of many. Later that year, on 30 September 2023, Francis created him a cardinal and assigned him the Diaconate of Saint Monica, a title that carried a particularly appropriate connection with his Augustinian life. In February 2025 Francis elevated him to the Order of Cardinal Bishops and assigned him the suburbicarian see of Albano. By then Prevost was no longer an obscure churchman. Yet outside Catholic institutional circles, his name was still unfamiliar to much of the wider public.
Then Pope Francis died in April 2025, and the Church entered the period of mourning and transition that eventually led the cardinals into conclave. The conclave began on 7 May. On the afternoon of 8 May, Robert Francis Prevost was elected Pope and chose the name Leo XIV. The choice was immediately intriguing. There had not been a Pope Leo since Leo XIII, who died in 1903 after a long pontificate remembered particularly for the social encyclical Rerum Novarum. A few days after his election, Leo XIV himself explained the connection. Leo XIII had confronted the social consequences of the first great industrial revolution; the new Pope saw the contemporary world facing another technological upheaval, particularly through artificial intelligence, with equally serious questions about labour, human dignity and justice. The papal name was therefore not an exercise in nostalgia. It was a declaration that an old tradition of Catholic social thought would be asked to confront very new machines.
His election was historic in other ways. Leo XIV became the first Pope from the United States and the first Augustinian Pope in the history of the Catholic Church. He was also a man whose biography complicated any simple national label. Born and educated in the United States, formed religiously within an international order, shaped pastorally by Peru, naturalized as a Peruvian citizen and professionally familiar with Rome, he arrived at the papacy carrying several worlds with him. He speaks English, Spanish, Portuguese, French and Italian. That linguistic ability is useful for any Pope, but in his case it also reflects lived experience rather than merely diplomatic preparation. He had already spent much of his adult life crossing cultural boundaries before the conclave required him to speak to the entire Church.
On 9 May 2025, the day after his election, he celebrated his first Mass with the College of Cardinals in the Sistine Chapel. On 18 May he presided over the Mass inaugurating his Petrine ministry. The contrast must have been extraordinary: the same man who had once worked in poor Peruvian parishes now stood before the world as Bishop of Rome. Yet the continuity in his own presentation was deliberate. He introduced himself through the language of peace, mission and Augustinian identity rather than through the language of personal triumph. Becoming Pope is one of the few promotions in the world for which the office comes with a balcony, Swiss Guards and the knowledge that historians will eventually analyse your choice of shoes. Leo XIV's first challenge was therefore to establish a recognisable voice without turning himself into a personality cult.
The early direction of his pontificate has shown why the name Leo was chosen. Social questions, the dignity of work, peace, technological power and the ethical implications of artificial intelligence have become recurring themes. In May 2026 he issued the encyclical Magnifica Humanitas, focused on safeguarding the human person in an age of artificial intelligence. In it, the technological question is treated not as a specialised concern for engineers but as a question about power, responsibility and what society believes a human being is worth. That emphasis links his current papacy directly with Leo XIII's nineteenth-century attempt to address the upheaval created by industrialisation. The machines are different; the moral problem is strangely familiar. When technology reorganises work, wealth and power faster than social institutions can react, who protects the person who is easiest to ignore?
This does not mean Leo XIV can be reduced to 'the Pope of artificial intelligence'. Popes inherit an institution that must respond simultaneously to wars, migration, poverty, internal Church debates, interreligious relations, diplomacy, pastoral life, family questions and the spiritual needs of more than a billion Catholics. His missionary background and long experience in Latin America inevitably influence the way observers interpret him, while his years as head of an international religious order and Prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops give him an unusually strong administrative profile. He is neither simply the American Pope nor simply the Peruvian missionary Pope nor simply the Vatican administrator. The interest lies precisely in the combination.
For Italy, his papacy also carries a special cultural significance. Every Pope, regardless of birthplace, becomes Bishop of Rome. That means his daily life is immediately woven into the history of an Italian city that has been shaped by the papacy for nearly two millennia. Leo XIV may have been born beside Lake Michigan and formed by years on the Pacific side of South America, but his office places him inside the architecture, rituals and public life of Rome. Saint Peter's Basilica, the Lateran, the Vatican, the Roman parishes and the crowds in Saint Peter's Square are not merely a backdrop for his pontificate. They are now part of his responsibility. Rome has a remarkable ability to adopt outsiders by giving them an impossible amount of history to carry.
There is also an intriguing circularity in his story. As a young Augustinian he came to Rome to study Canon Law. He was ordained a priest in the city in 1982 and then left for missionary life. Decades later he returned as Prefect of one of the most important Vatican departments. Then, in 2025, the city that had once been a place of study became his episcopal see. Few biographies offer such a clean geographical arc: Chicago gave him his childhood and education, Peru gave him a large part of his pastoral identity, the Augustinian Order gave him a global horizon, and Rome eventually brought all of those experiences together.
What kind of Pope Leo XIV will ultimately be is a question that cannot yet be answered. Papacies are judged over years, sometimes decades, and often differently by each generation. The temptation to define a new Pope immediately is enormous because modern media dislikes unfinished stories. Yet Leo XIV's biography suggests that patience may be especially appropriate. His career was built less on dramatic public gestures than on long periods of work: eleven years in Trujillo, twelve years leading the Augustinians, years in Chiclayo, then the demanding work of selecting bishops in Rome. He became globally famous in one evening, but very little about the road that brought him there happened overnight.
Perhaps that is the most interesting part of his story. Robert Francis Prevost did not emerge from nowhere when the curtains opened on the balcony of Saint Peter's. Behind that moment stood a Chicago family committed to education and parish life, a mathematics student at Villanova, a young Augustinian studying in Rome, a missionary priest in northern Peru, a canon lawyer, a seminary professor, a parish pastor, a religious superior travelling the world, a bishop in Chiclayo and finally a cardinal trusted by Pope Francis with one of the Church's most delicate responsibilities. The white cassock made him visible to everyone at once. The life underneath it had been taking shape for seventy years.
And so Pope Leo XIV's story is not simply the story of the first American-born Pope. It is the story of a man formed by several countries, several languages and several kinds of service before being asked to lead the Catholic Church. It is a story that begins in Chicago, becomes deeply rooted in Peru and eventually arrives in Rome, where an ancient institution once again placed itself in the hands of someone whose biography could hardly be described as provincial. His pontificate is still being written. That is precisely why following it is so interesting: history, for once, is not safely finished and filed away. It is happening in front of us.
If you love discovering the people, places, traditions and stories that connect Italy with the wider world, follow Made in Italy Stories. We tell Italy from the inside, with the curiosity to look beyond the postcard and the patience to understand the history behind the image.
#MadeInItalyStories #PopeLeoXIV #LeoXIV #RobertFrancisPrevost #Vatican #VaticanCity #Rome #CatholicHistory #ItalianHistory #HistoryOfRome #SaintPetersBasilica #Papacy #CatholicChurch #Augustinians #SaintAugustine #Peru #Chicago #ChurchHistory #MadeInItaly #DiscoverItaly